Beyond Likes and Followers: The Metrics That Actually Matter for Local Businesses

Let's be honest: vanity metrics don't pay rent.

You can have 50K Instagram followers, 100K post impressions, and a "viral" TikTok that got 2 million views—but if those numbers don't translate to real customers, your business is in trouble.

Small businesses don't have the luxury of chasing clout. Every marketing dollar must work. So let's cut through the noise and focus on the 3 metrics that actually matter—and how to track them with Onlure.

The Vanity Metrics Trap

Here's what most marketing platforms want you to care about:

These metrics feel good—who doesn't love seeing "100K impressions!"—but they're leading indicators at best. They don't tell you if your marketing actually worked.

Ask yourself:

No. You need revenue. And revenue comes from customers.

The Only 3 Metrics That Matter

If you're a small business—cafe, boutique, salon, gym, restaurant—here are the metrics you should obsess over:

1. Conversions (Real Results)

Definition: How many people took the action you wanted (visited your store, made a purchase, booked an appointment) as a result of creator content.

Why it matters: Conversions = revenue. A customer who shows up because of a creator's post is a real person who walked through your door.

How to track it:

Example: A Kensington Market vintage shop partnered with 3 local fashion creators.

That's a metric you can take to the bank.

2. Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC)

Definition: How much you spent to acquire each new customer.

Formula: ``` CAC = Total Marketing Spend ÷ New Customers Acquired ```

Why it matters: If it costs you $50 to acquire a customer who spends $30, you're losing money. You need CAC to be lower than your average customer lifetime value (LTV).

How to track it with Onlure:

Let's say you book a creator for $200 for a collaboration.

Compare that to:

Creator marketing through Onlure is 3-8× cheaper because authentic content drives real visits, not just clicks.

3. Repeat Rate (Customer Retention)

Definition: What percentage of first-time customers come back for a second visit?

Why it matters: Acquiring a customer is expensive. Keeping them is cheap. A customer who returns 5× is worth 5× more than a one-time visitor.

How to track it:

Example: A Yorkville wellness studio found that customers referred by a local fitness creator had a 35% repeat rate, while customers from Instagram ads had a 12% repeat rate.

Lesson: Quality of traffic matters more than quantity. Micro-creators with engaged audiences drive better long-term customers.

Free Tier vs. Premium Analytics

Onlure offers two levels of insight:

Free Tier (Basic Features)

Good for: Businesses just getting started, testing creator marketing for the first time.

Premium Tier ($49/month - Full Insights)

Good for: Businesses running multiple collaborations, optimizing creator partnerships, scaling campaigns.

How to Calculate True ROI

Here's the math every small business should do:

Step 1: Track your costs

Step 2: Track your revenue

Step 3: Calculate profit

Step 4: Calculate ROI ``` ROI = (Net Profit ÷ Total Cost) × 100 ROI = ($525 ÷ $75) × 100 = 700% ```

That's a 7× return. Show me an Instagram ad campaign that delivers that.

Real Toronto Success Stories

Queen West Cafe: 40% Foot Traffic Increase

Kensington Market Vintage Shop: 200+ New Customers

Yorkville Wellness Studio: Classes Fully Booked

Stop Chasing Vanity Metrics. Start Tracking Revenue.

If you take one thing away from this article, let it be this:

Likes don't matter. Followers don't matter. Impressions don't matter.

Customers matter. Revenue matters. ROI matters.

Onlure gives you the tools to track what actually moves your business forward. No more guessing if your marketing is working. No more "brand awareness" excuses.

Just cold, hard data—and the profits to show for it.

---

*Want help calculating your marketing ROI? Email us at support@onlure.ca*